Some makers use both types of construction
in building custom furniture and custom cabinets. Now lets look at
these two options and their strong and weak points.
Solid wood
furniture
This
means all exposed parts are made of the same species of all natural wood,
with no other materials included, such as plywood or particle board.
Advantages of Solid Wood:
-
Practical. The durability
of solid wood furniture is high on the list. Scratches, dings, dents,
water marks, stains can all be repaired. Obviously, the worse the damage
the more expensive, but it is certainly easier and less expensive than
veneer furniture.
Disadvantages of Solid Wood:
-
split. When exposed to extreme
atmospheric conditions, solid wood furniture will expand or contract, and may split along
the grain of the wood. Some makers use a "floating case system" in which table and
case-piece surfaces are attached using a bracket method or elongated
holes for screws to slide. This enables furniture to respond to
environmental changes without damage. As a rule, though, avoid exposing
pieces to strong sunlight or direct heat sources.
Veneer furniture
begins with thin layers of wood glued together with the grain at right
angles over a thick core. This crisscross design reduces the chances of
splitting or cracking. Plus, the glue is the same strong, waterproof
adhesive used in aircraft and marine construction, so the end result is
actually stronger than the natural wood. Many people mistakenly assume
that veneered furniture is inferior to or cheaper than solid wood;
however, veneers quite often are used for high end furniture pieces and
it can be more costly than solid wood.
Good quality
veneer furniture will have a solid core and the legs, posts, doors or
drawer fronts will be straight-grain solid wood.
Advantages of Veneer:
-
Beautiful. The best, most
interesting logs are cut into veneer. This is largely an economic
decision--sellers and veneer makers can make more money from a high
quality log sliced into veneer than they can from sawing it into boards.
And certain cuts, such as burls, are structurally unsound in 'the
solid'. These beautiful woods can rarely be utilized unless they're
sliced into veneer
-
Environmentally kind. Saw timber is
typically sawn into 1" thick boards. The saw cuts a kerf between boards
1/4" thick that winds up as sawdust. Veneer is not cut from the log but
sliced with a knife (like lunch meat) into 1/32" leaves or sheets. That
produces 32 veneer surfaces for every 1 that is gotten from a board and
with no wood wasted as sawdust another 8 sheets where the sawblade would
have gone. That's 40 surfaces of wood veneer for every 1 of solid wood.
-
Creates new design possibilities.
Since veneer is so thin and is glued to a stable substrate it allows
designs and arrangements of the wood that would fail in solid wood.
Solid wood, even kiln-dried, moves or works from summer through winter
through summer again. A radiant table top would be impossible in solid
lumber because the seams would open in winter and swell tightly shut in
summer. Cross grain designs such as aprons and edge bandings are also
impossible in solids. Solid burls are also largely unusable but
frequently used in veneer.
-
Stable. Since veneer is glued to a
stable substrate it produces surfaces not prone to warp or splitting or
seasonal movement.
-
Substrates. Plywood and medium
density fiberboard, the substrates used for some furniture, are made from
low quality trees. This means a market is provided the landowner for
these trees. This leads to better forests over time since the trees
remaining grow better and faster with less competition for resources.
Its like weeding your garden only a lot bigger.
Disadvantages Veneer:
-
Thin. This is more of a problem for the
builder than the buyer. Sand-through in preparation for finishing is
'touching the third rail' of woodworking. Such pieces are almost
impossible to repair and frequently involve 're-design' (as in cutting
off the sanded through area) or making a speculative, difficult repair
which can be difficult to hide. Once the piece is completed thickness of
the veneer is of no concern.
-
Blisters, delaminates, peel back at edges.
These can only be satisfactorily prevented by proper construction
materials and techniques. Early in the 20th century much mass-produced,
low quality veneer furniture was made that haunts furniture makers to
this day. Construction techniques and materials have improved
considerably in the past few decades to the point that delaminating is
no longer a legitimate concern. Hide glue is used only in a few special
applications and has been superceded by aliphatic and resorcinol glues.
'Hammer veneering' and cumbersome, mechanical presses have been replaced
by vacuum presses which insure good clamping (and facilitate design
possibilities by allowing veneering of curved surfaces).
-
The edge thing. Since veneer is glued
to a plywood or medium density fiberboard substrate the edges must be
covered. The best solution involves a strip of solid wood that opens
more design possibilities. The edging can be wide or narrow, match the
veneer panel or contrast, can further incorporate veneer which can be
cross grain or at a 45 degree angle, can be set off by a narrow strip of
inlay, etc. A workable solution but one that is generally avoided is to run
the veneer right up to the edge of the piece and cover the edge with a
strip of veneer. This can make for 'hard' edges susceptible to peel back
and is best avoided.
RJ Spomer Cabinetmaker
|